Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Federal Government?

[After the class simulation]

What do you think about the new proposal to have all nations 1) follow my rules 2) pay taxes to me 3) settle all issues in your individual nations through me?

Give some suggestions on how this proposal CAN work.

27 comments:

Anonymous said...

I DON'T REALLY AGREE BECAUSE WHY DO WE HAVE TO FOLLOW ALL YOUR RULES WHAT IF ITS NOT REALLY FARE AND STUFF LIKE THAT. I DON'T WANT TO PAY SO MANY TAXES BECAUSE FIRST OF ALL I HAVE TO CONTROL THE COST'S OF MY NATION AND THINGS ALL THAT. IN SOME WAY I KIND OFF AGREE BECAUSE YOU UN US AS A NATION AND YOU NEED MONEY TO CONTROL OUR NATION.I DON'T AGREE THAT WE HAVE TO SETTLE THE PROBLEMS WITH YOU BECAUSE WE SHOULD HAVE A REP OR CONGRESS.

Anonymous said...

I think what you said about the new proposal is a good idea for the nations to have the same laws. The taxes thing i don't care because taxes are normal. I don't care if we have a problem and we come to you to fix the problem because it will be easier to us.

Anonymous said...

i do not agree because why do we have to pay tax of. i agree with every thing else though.

Anonymous said...

1. WHY FOLLOW YOUR RULES IF IT IS OUR NATION? WE MAKE THE RULES

2.MAYBE A LITTLE BIT OF TAXES BECAUSE YOU CAME UP WITH THE IDEA OF US MAKING A CITY BUT NOT A LOT OF TAXES.

3.YES WE CAN BECAUSE YOU CAN BE THERE TO HELP US OUT A LITTLE.

Randy 8e said...

I think that one of those rules sound greedy. The government can't just ask for the tax. That just shows their desire for money. The citizens should pay taxes without being asked.

The rules thing might be fair or unfair. It depends on what the rules are.

The proposal will work if they take the number 2 rule out. It just sounds greedy out there. The rest just seem fine.
If there is a reason that the people should pay taxes, they will. The people won't want to pay the taxes upon request.

Anonymous said...

I believe that this proposal is not completely fair. The reason why i believe this is it's almost as if it becoming a dictator ship. We pay taxes to you make the rules we hardly have any say in the things that you proposed it highly unfair. Suppose someones nation does not propose that much profit what will happen then. We should have the right to to disagree with certain rules instead of following them all with no say.

Anonymous said...

I dont mind tax but 1000 dollars? What is it going to? Same set of laws Plenty of nations recently have their own versions of laws, and they dont HAVE to agree to the laws aslong as the PEOPLE dont like it. IT"S THEIR NATION. The fact that you want us to base discipline on your perspective. Thats very altruistic of you. Many people do not have YOUR point of view. Some may not agree with you or share the same feelings, evidently no one does. Most nations arerepublican government and the people should hve say in your biased desicions.

Anonymous said...

i agree and i don't agree at the same time because first all the nations following the same rules that is good because then it will be easer and everything would be organized but at the same time i think that we should be able to have are own rules because it is are nation and are project and the same for paying taxes we should be able to choose if we want to pay taxes or not

Anonymous said...

I DON'T AGREE BECAUSE WHY SHOULD BE FOLLOW YOUR RULES IF IS ARE NATION WE SHOULD MAKE ARE OWN RULES.AND WE SHOULD KNOW HOW TO CONTROL ARE OWN NATIONS.
I DON'T WANT TO PAY SO MUCH TAXES BECAUSE AM GOING TO NEED A LOT OF MONEY FOR MY NATION. ECT
I DON'T AGREE WE SHOULD SETTLE ALL ISSUES IN YOUR INDIVIDUAL NATION THROUGH YOU BECAUSE AS SAD WE SHOULD KNOW HOW TO CONTROL ARE OWN NATION AND HELP IT FOR THE BEST.

Anonymous said...

I don't agree with the proposal.The reason i say that it because,we have too many things to worry about to have to come up with money every month.the way that i think the proposal can work is by letting everyone do what the want.

Anonymous said...

i dont think that its far because we are running our own nation and we should be able to run it the way we want to because we have the power of the nation i thoet that was the whole reason why we are doing this project

Randy 8e said...

Troy doesn't the government need money? Well yes I think people need to do what they want. Too many rules is no fun.

Randy 8e said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Randy when you said "I think that one of those rules sound greedy" i knew you were talking about the taxes. thats not being greedy thats like saying the govn't is being greedy by making taxes no its going back to schools and stuff.

Jackson said...

Thank you Yahkeemah. I also believe that it would make things easier if you have one set of laws.

Randy 8e said...

Sorry double post glitch

Anonymous said...

Yahkeemah they are taking advantage of the people and you are letting them. where do you think $1000 can possibly go to? What if her choice of discipline is not fair and you see this? Dont you believe that notevery one has the same perspective.

Randy 8e said...

Well i meant it shows desire for money. They can't just ask for taxes

Anonymous said...

I think your proposal is somewhat fair in a way i agree because when solving problems we might need help because some groups wont be able to solve problems together as a whole so they might need help. The taxes we can discuss or make an agreement. The proposal for all nations to have the same rules is a good idea because if some citizens decide to leave their nation and go to our they would be a little confused and wont know the laws if all the nations have the same laws then they wont break them. Some suggestions are to lower the taxes because we need the money for our nation. One question how would we get the money.

~d3Ysh@~ {b3b@} said...

Eileen if you don't want your nation to pay taxes then how is the president is going to get paid or other people ??

Anonymous said...

I think that we all should have the same laws in each nation because we all want our citizens to feel as COMFORTABLE AS POSSIBLE so if they are traveling from another nation nothing will be different so they don't have to settle in and learn new laws and since they live in another nation things that they can do there might be illegal here if we have different laws. I don't think we shouldn't pay taxes because we need the money for our nation. ms. Jackson you are starting to sound like a dictator.

Randy 8e said...

Not trying to be off topic but why is Kimberly here?

Anonymous said...

I STRONGLY DISAGREE WITH YOUR INJUSTICE PROPOSAL. I DISAGREE WITH THIS BECAUSE I FEEL THAT YOU HAVE PUT OUR GROUP THROUGH A LOT OF TRESS BY HAVING US THINK THAT WE ARE GOING TO HAVE OUR OWN NATION WITH OUR OWN RULES AND REGULATIONS. WHEN DID YOU AND MR.R DECIDE TO DO THIS.

Anonymous said...

Amber your right about the perpective thing. But don't you think teens have perpectives too. what mean they probably don't think its fair if only adults can go to cubs ect...

Anonymous said...

thats not right its injustice. i wouldn't be able to live in that kind of nation. really i think it cant work, i no my rights and that is just taking away my natural born rights.

Get Online project said...

I think that if it will help my citizen then i will pay but if it makes things worse than i would stop immidiatly I would also make a vote with it first of my grup

Anonymous said...

I do and do not agree. I don't agree about having the nations beacuse running a nation takes allot of money. building homes, running busnesis takes allot of work I do not agree that you should have all the nation. I do agree that you should get paid beacuse as the leader and having to do plenty of work you should get payed very well. I don't agree about "following your rules" as our own nation we should have our own laws. paying taxes to you is not a problem for me beacuse it's going to you and as i said you should get paid for some of the work.